The Five Forgotten Christmases
Some betrayals happen gradually, so slowly that you don’t recognize them as betrayals at all until you’re standing in the wreckage of what you thought was love. Some secrets slip out through the innocent voices of children who haven’t yet learned that adults lie to protect their cruelty. And sometimes, when you’ve been invisible long enough, the most powerful thing you can do is disappear entirely – only to reappear on your own terms.
Eleanor Reynolds was sixty-two years old when her grandson accidentally revealed a truth that would change everything. She wasn’t supposed to discover their Christmas plans this year, just as she hadn’t been supposed to know about them for the past four years. The invitation that never came wasn’t meant to be discussed in her presence.
But when eight-year-old Ethan FaceTimed his grandmother because he missed her, family secrets had a way of tumbling out like toys from an overstuffed closet.
The Accidental Truth
“Grandma, why aren’t you coming for Christmas again?” Ethan’s innocent face filled Eleanor’s iPad screen, his forehead wrinkled with genuine confusion that cut straight to her heart.
“What do you mean, sweetheart?” Eleanor kept her voice light and steady, though something cold and familiar settled in her stomach like a stone.
“Dad said you’re busy this year. Are you going somewhere fun? Can I come with you?”
Behind Ethan, Eleanor could see the familiar wallpaper of her son Michael’s living room, holiday decorations already adorning every surface with the kind of festive abundance that spoke of careful planning and excited anticipation. It was only December 1st, but the Christmas machine was already in full motion.
Without her.
“I’m not sure what your dad means, Ethan,” Eleanor said carefully. “No one’s talked to me about Christmas plans yet.”
Ethan’s little face scrunched up in the way children’s faces do when adult logic doesn’t align with observable reality. “But everyone’s coming to our house. Mom’s making lists. She has a special folder called Christmas 2023 with everyone’s names. I saw it.”
Eleanor felt her chest tighten. “Is my name on that list, Ethan?”
Before he could answer, a perfectly manicured hand appeared in the frame, taking the iPad away from him. Eleanor’s daughter-in-law Victoria’s face replaced Ethan’s, her expression shifting from mild annoyance to carefully controlled politeness when she realized Eleanor was on the call.
The story doesn’t end here –
it continues on the next page.
TAP → NEXT PAGE → 👇
